200 reports

Trace the evidence

Distinguish primary documents from reporting about them. Follow the source link where supplied.

Severity, not sentiment

Low / Medium / High is scoped by documented harm and evidence — not virality.

Parent-company aware

Reports on parent conglomerates roll through to their subsidiary brand pages.

Response invited

Brands can submit on-the-record corrections; verified updates are appended in-line.

Why we log without punishing

Boycott feeds and rating apps often deduct points for any negative headline. That rewards brands with better PR teams, not better practices. EthiCompare separates the two: structural scoring measures verified inputs (certifications, materials, ownership), while this tracker surfaces reported behavior so you can decide how heavily it should weigh.

When a controversy is confirmed at practice level — a certification revoked, a supplier dropped, a regulator's finding upheld — it triggers a rescore. Otherwise it stays here as context.

Cross-reference before you decide

A controversy on a subsidiary is often best read against its parent. Use /brands/ownership to see which conglomerate is behind an "indie" label, and /recalls for live safety notices that may be linked.

For patterns across a whole category — greenwashing in fashion, animal testing in beauty — start from a topic cluster and drill down.

Separate the allegation, finding and response

A headline can refer to an allegation, an investigation, a settlement or a final decision. These are not interchangeable. Read the dated source and the brand's response, then identify which company, activity and period are actually covered.

Hands comparing documents and notes beside an open laptop
AI-generated illustration; not evidence about a real product, certification or case.
  1. Trace the source

    Open the linked document. Distinguish original regulator or court material from reporting that describes it; several stories may all repeat one underlying source.

  2. Establish scope and status

    Check the legal entity, jurisdiction, date and whether a decision is final, contested or under appeal. Do not extend a finding to every subsidiary or product without evidence.

  3. Read what changed

    Look for a response, correction or documented remediation. A promise is not the same as completed action, while an old allegation may have a later resolution.

Separate the allegation, finding and response: evidence comparison
Source statusWhat it supportsWhat to avoid concluding
Allegation or complaintThat a claim has been madeThat misconduct has been proven
InvestigationThat an authority is examining the issueThat the outcome is already decided
Decision or settlementThe findings or terms stated in that documentAn admission beyond the actual wording or a finding against unrelated brands
Brand responseThe company's stated position or proposed actionIndependent confirmation that remediation is complete

Report counts measure catalogue coverage, not the frequency of harm. Severity labels are editorial context; this tracker is not a legal determination or a comprehensive record.

Controversy tracker — FAQ

How does a controversy get onto this list?+

Entries should be dated and supported by a credible source. Regulator documents, court filings and brand statements are primary records; investigative reporting is secondary coverage. Read the source and distinguish an allegation from a finding. Rumours and unattributed social posts are not sufficient evidence.

Does a controversy drop a brand's ethics score?+

Not automatically. Ethics scores weigh verified structural signals (certifications, ingredients, materials, ownership). A controversy adds context and, when it maps to a confirmed practice change, can trigger a rescore. Individual allegations don't deduct points on their own.

How is severity decided?+

Low = single-source reporting or contested claim. Medium = confirmed by regulator or multiple outlets, limited scope. High = ongoing pattern, safety recall, court judgment, or documented harm at scale.

Can a brand respond to a report?+

Yes. When a brand publishes an on-the-record response, correction, or remediation timeline, we append it to the entry and link the source. Send corrections to hello@ethicompare.com.

Why do resolved issues still appear?+

Historical accountability matters. A resolved 2019 issue may still inform a purchasing decision in 2026 — especially if remediation was partial or hidden behind a rebrand.