How we score products

The EthiCompare ethics score is an AI-assisted catalogue assessment on a 0–100 scale. Read the five recorded dimensions, supporting evidence and limitations before treating a ranking as a recommendation.

  1. 1. Sourcing

    Origin of important materials and ingredients, traceability claims and the documentation available to check them. A country of origin alone does not establish responsible sourcing.

  2. 2. Labour

    Information about working conditions, supplier disclosure, trade standards and audits. A commitment is not evidence that every supplier has met it.

  3. 3. Environment

    Material choices, packaging, reuse, repair and end-of-life information. The catalogue assessment is not a measured lifecycle footprint.

  4. 4. Animal welfare

    Animal-derived materials, testing policies and relevant certification scope. Vegan composition and an animal-testing policy answer different questions.

  5. 5. Transparency

    How specific, current and traceable the available disclosures are. Missing information limits confidence; it is not proof of misconduct.

Red flags that need independent investigation

  • A certification mark that cannot be matched to the claimed product or company scope.
  • A dated regulator finding concerning the exact product or legal entity.
  • Conflicting ingredient, ownership or supply-chain information.
  • A safety notice covering the relevant model or batch.
  • An allegation presented as though it were a final decision.

Limitations & honest caveats

No score captures everything. We rely on public information; brands that disclose less may score lower than they "deserve" simply because we can't verify their claims. The score is a starting point, not a verdict. Product notes and labels may require further verification with the original issuer.

Small brands with fewer resources for formal certification are structurally disadvantaged. Where we can, public disclosures such as a factory list, an ingredient breakdown or a take-back policy can help assess transparency, but should not be treated as equivalent to an independent audit.

Categories differ. A 78 in fashion means something different from a 78 in food — the total is not a reproducible calculation in the current importer, and the evidence differs by category. Compare like with like first.

About EthiCompare · Corrections & press · Certifications guide · Transparency

Score bands, in plain English

90–100
Exemplary

The highest catalogue score band; not a guarantee of complete disclosure or independently verified compliance.

75–89
Strong

A relatively high catalogue assessment. Verify any certification or ingredient requirement separately.

60–74
Above average

An intermediate catalogue score. The label is not a measured comparison with the whole market.

40–59
Mixed

A lower catalogue assessment. Read the actual notes rather than inferring a specific failing from the number.

0–39
Weak

The lowest catalogue band. It is not by itself a legal finding or evidence that a product is unsafe.

What you can verify in the original evidence

Certification claims
  • Named standard and current directory listing
  • Exact company, product or material scope
  • Certificate or licence information where available
Ingredients and materials
  • Full formula or composition
  • Animal-derived inputs and ambiguous origins
  • Restrictions that apply to the specific use and market
Supply chain
  • Dated factory or supplier disclosure
  • Scope and origin of any audit report
  • Distinction between commitments and documented outcomes
Packaging
  • Material composition and stated recycled content
  • Refill compatibility and availability
  • Acceptance by local recycling or composting services
Brand information
  • Legal entity and ownership
  • Date and status of a regulator finding or allegation
  • Evidence of completed remediation rather than a promise

Claims that need more specific evidence

  • "Clean", "green", "conscious", "eco" — their meaning depends on the claim, standard and jurisdiction; vague wording is not enough.
  • "Made with recycled content" without a stated percentage.
  • "Sustainably sourced" without a named standard.
  • Charity-of-the-month tie-ins as a proxy for ethics.
  • Founder biographies, mission statements, or brand story alone.

How this compares to other systems

EthiCompare
Approach: AI-assisted catalogue assessment and product comparison
Coverage: Products recorded in the catalogue
Updates: Catalogue and editorial refreshes; not continuous verification of every claim
Monetisation: Some retailer links are affiliate links; placement is not sold
Certification bodies
Approach: Assessment against a named standard with a defined scope
Coverage: Participating companies, products, materials or operations
Updates: The programme's own surveillance and renewal requirements
Monetisation: Fees and funding arrangements vary by programme
Editorial buying guides
Approach: Selection and analysis under the publisher's stated criteria
Coverage: A selected market or category; not necessarily a complete survey
Updates: Depends on the publisher and article
Monetisation: Check each publisher's affiliate and sponsorship disclosures

Read the score alongside the evidence

The composite score condenses several different questions into one number. It is useful for narrowing a category, but it cannot tell you whether an item meets a medical need, a strict dietary rule or every personal value. Read the individual evidence before making those decisions.

A product assessment desk with a cotton garment, glass bottle, carton, notes and calculator
AI-generated illustration; not evidence about a real product, certification or case.
  1. Compare like with like

    Start within the same category and intended use. Evidence for a textile and a food product comes from different standards even when their totals look similar.

  2. Check your non-negotiables

    Verify animal-derived ingredients, testing policy, allergens or certification scope separately. A strong composite score cannot replace a requirement that matters to you.

  3. Read dates and gaps

    Check when sources were published and what remains undisclosed. A missing fact is not proof of misconduct, but it limits how confidently a claim can be assessed.

Read the score alongside the evidence: evidence comparison
SignalUseful forNot a substitute for
Ethics scoreComparing recorded evidence within a categoryA safety certification or a complete lifecycle assessment
Customer star ratingUnderstanding reported customer experienceIndependent verification of labour or environmental claims
CertificationChecking a defined standard and scopeA guarantee covering every ethical dimension
Published priceChecking affordability at the listed point in timeAn ethics score or a guaranteed checkout total

What the published ethics score measures

The 0–100 ethics score is a catalogue assessment intended to help compare products, not a laboratory result or an official certification. Product records also contain a five-part breakdown for sourcing, labour, environment, animal welfare and transparency. These fields make different concerns visible, but a single total inevitably compresses trade-offs. A product can be stronger on one issue and weaker on another, so a high total does not establish that it satisfies every personal requirement.

There is an important distinction between the editorial criteria described on this site and the way a listing's score enters the catalogue. The current automated importer asks AI to propose both the total and the five breakdown values, and saves them as structured fields. It does not derive every total through a reproducible, fixed-weight calculation from independently verified evidence. The published score therefore needs to be read critically alongside sources and product notes; it should not be described as an independently audited measurement.

How to judge the strength of the supporting evidence

A current certificate covering the relevant product is stronger support for a certification claim than a retailer badge. A dated supplier list is useful evidence of disclosure, but it does not by itself establish living wages or safe conditions at every factory. A brand's sustainability report can explain its stated actions while still being self-reported. Identify what a document actually supports, who produced it, the time period it covers and which entity it concerns before accepting a broader conclusion.

The product importer's web check is a brand-existence safeguard, not a full product audit. It reduces the risk of publishing an invented brand; it does not independently confirm every certification, ingredient, price, review or score proposed by AI. When a claim is important to your purchase, follow the source back to the manufacturer, certifier or relevant authority. A fluent summary, a convincing photograph and a precise-looking number are not substitutes for that verification.

Missing information and small score differences

An undisclosed fact and a negative finding are different. Missing supplier information means you cannot assess that part of the chain confidently; it is not proof that abuse occurred. Equally, the absence of a controversy entry is not proof of an unblemished history. Catalogue coverage depends on the information available, the entities searched and the dates of the sources. Small businesses may provide less formal documentation even when they have useful practices, while large businesses can publish extensive reports that leave important questions unanswered.

There is no validated uncertainty margin that makes a one- or two-point gap a meaningful difference in real-world impact. Compare products with the same intended use and inspect the dimensions that matter to you. For example, if both detergents meet your practical needs but only one has a verifiable animal-testing policy, that policy can be a more useful tie-breaker than an 82 versus an 84. This is a hypothetical decision example, not a measured comparison of catalogue products.

Ethics scores, customer ratings and prices stay separate

An ethics score summarises the catalogue's ethical assessment. A star rating describes reported customer experience, where genuine review evidence is available. A price describes an offer at a particular point in time. These signals answer different questions. A product can be popular with customers while lacking transparent sourcing, or have useful ethical evidence while being unsuitable for your skin, dimensions or budget. Do not interpret customer satisfaction as independent proof of environmental or labour performance.

Before relying on a review summary, check the source, product variant, review count and date where supplied. AI-assisted catalogue text is not a customer review, and a retailer rating is not a rating of the brand's ethics. Likewise, a dollar-sign tier is a rough price grouping, not a numerical offer. Always check a retailer's current product page and checkout total. Keeping these distinctions clear is more informative than combining them into an apparently authoritative recommendation.

Updates, corrections and the limits of freshness

Catalogue records and editorial pages are maintained through separate update processes. A recent page refresh does not establish that every source, certificate or supplier fact was checked again that day. Read dates on the underlying documents and distinguish a new summary from new evidence. Changes to ownership, formulas, packaging or certification scope can make an older conclusion less useful even when the product name remains the same.

If you spot a problem, report the exact product or page through our press and contact page. Include the disputed claim, a link to the original evidence, its date and the relevant product or company scope. This makes a correction easier to assess than a general statement that a score is wrong. Do not use this catalogue as a safety approval, medical recommendation, legal finding or a complete lifecycle assessment; it is a starting point for informed comparison, with important limitations made explicit.

These examples explain how to interpret the site; they are not measured product comparisons. Scores reflect available evidence and should not be presented as customer reviews.

Methodology FAQ

Are the scores calculated with fixed weights?+

Not by the current automated importer. It asks AI to propose a total and five breakdown values, then stores them. The total is not a reproducible fixed-weight calculation from independently verified inputs.

Does the brand check verify every product claim?+

No. The web check is intended to prevent invented brands. It does not independently verify every certification, formula, review, price or score.

Does missing supply-chain data prove poor conditions?+

No. It limits what can be assessed. Missing disclosure is different from a documented negative finding.

Does a high score mean a product is vegan or safe for me?+

No. Check animal-derived ingredients, certification scope, allergens and suitability separately. An ethics score is not a safety approval or medical recommendation.

Do you factor in price?+

Price is a separate catalogue field. Numerical budget hubs filter recorded prices; dollar-sign tiers are only approximate groups. Confirm the current retailer total.

How can I report a correction?+

Use the press and contact page with the specific claim, product, original source and date. A refreshed page does not necessarily mean every underlying fact has been re-verified.