Decomposition Notebook (Lined, Classic) vs Coastal Recycled Ocean Plastic Retractable Pens

Overview

Michael Roger's Decomposition Notebook (lined, classic) and Wisdom Supply Co.'s Coastal Recycled Ocean Plastic Retractable Pens are both top-tier ethical choices in the Office & Stationery category. The notebook scores an impressive 92/100 ethics, while the pens earn 89/100. Both are affordably priced and boast strong environmental credentials, but they serve different needs: one is a classic paper notebook, the other a set of retractable pens made from recycled ocean plastic.

Ethics diff

The Michael Roger notebook leads with a 92 ethics score, bolstered by FSC Certification (ensuring responsible forestry) and membership in 1% for the Planet. Wisdom Supply Co.’s pens, at 89, carry B Corp Certification (rigorous social/environmental standards), 1% for the Planet, and Global Recycled Standard (GRS) for the recycled plastic content. While both are excellent, the notebook edges ahead due to its higher score and the FSC label's direct link to sustainable sourcing. However, the pens’ B Corp certification adds a layer of holistic corporate accountability that some users may prioritize.

Everyday use

The Michael Roger notebook is ideal for note-taking, journaling, or sketching—its classic lined pages are versatile for students or professionals. The Wisdom Supply pens are retractable, making them convenient for quick note capture, and they write smoothly. If you need a reusable, long-term writing tool, the notebook wins. For disposable but eco-conscious writing instruments, the pens are a solid choice. Both are lightweight and portable, but the notebook offers more durability for daily carry.

Value

Both products are priced at the same affordability level ($). The notebook provides about 200 pages of FSC-certified paper, offering long-term value for the cost. The pens, sold in packs, give multiple writing tools but may be replaced more frequently. Considering their ethics scores and certifications, the notebook offers slightly higher value per dollar due to its longevity and higher ethics rating.

Bottom line

The Michael Roger Decomposition Notebook wins overall thanks to its superior ethics score (92 vs 89), FSC certification, and greater everyday utility as a reusable, classic stationery item. While the Wisdom Supply pens are excellent for eco-friendly disposability, the notebook’s sustainability and versatility make it the better ethical and practical choice for most shoppers.