Earth Sourced Perfectly Natural Cleanser vs The Deodorant (Fragrance-Free)

Overview

Paula's Choice Earth Sourced Perfectly Natural Cleanser and Necessaire The Deodorant (Fragrance-Free) both score near-perfect ethics ratings — 92/100 and 91/100 respectively — and sit in the same mid-range price bracket ($$). The Paula's Choice product is a gentle, eco-friendly face wash formulated with natural ingredients, while Necessaire offers a high-performance, aluminum-free deodorant focused on sensitive skin and climate action. Both are certified by Leaping Bunny and B Corp, but they differ in additional certifications and intended use cases.

Ethics diff

Paula's Choice edges ahead with a 92/100 ethics score, bolstered by its FSC Certified packaging and a fully transparent supply chain. Necessaire earns its 91/100 through Climate Neutral certification and its 1% for the Planet membership, which donates proceeds to environmental nonprofits. Both brands are Leaping Bunny certified (no animal testing) and B Corp certified, but Paula's Choice's FSC certification gives it a slight advantage in sustainable sourcing, while Necessaire leads in carbon neutrality and charitable giving.

Everyday use

The Paula's Choice cleanser is a daily face wash for normal to dry skin, using natural surfactants and soothing botanicals. It lathers gently and rinses clean, ideal for morning and evening routines. The Necessaire deodorant is a stick formula with a subtle, fragrance-free finish that neutralizes odor without irritation. It glides on smoothly and lasts through a full day, making it perfect for high-sensitivity users who want a non-greasy, fast-absorbing product. Both are easy to incorporate into a low-waste regimen if you buy refills (where available).

Value

At $$, both products are competitively priced for their category. Paula's Choice offers a 177ml (6 oz) bottle that lasts about 2-3 months with daily use. Necessaire's deodorant is a 50ml (1.7 oz) stick with a similar lifespan. While the face wash provides more direct volume, deodorant typically costs less per use. Considering the ethics and ingredient quality, both deliver strong value for the money, though the deodorant may be a better investment for those seeking a single high-impact swap.

Bottom line

If you need a daily face cleanser with top-tier environmental packaging and a higher ethics score, choose Paula's Choice. If your priority is a high-performance, fragrance-free deodorant that actively supports climate initiatives and charities, go with Necessaire. Both are excellent, but the winner depends on your personal care needs.