The verdict
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count worth it?
Qualified yes — Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is solid on some criteria but has gaps worth checking before you buy. It holds 2 verified certifications (AP Seal (ASTM D-4236), Non-Toxic). Priced in the $ band.
- Cruelty-freeUnverified
- VeganUnverified
- Plastic-free packagingYes
- Recyclable / compostableUnverified
- Palm-oil safeUnverified
- Certified organicUnverified
- Fair labourUnverified
Crayola
Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count
Ethics Score
Composite of certifications, ingredient analysis, and sustainability practices.
Certifications
Buy From
* Affiliate links help support EthiCompare's mission.
Customer Rating
Best for
Budget-conscious parents and teachers who need non-toxic, kid-safe crayons with earthy colors
AI Ethics Review
A budget-friendly, widely available crayon set using recycled paper wrappers and non-toxic pigments, but with limited deep sustainability commitments from a mass-market brand.
Gallery
Claim-by-claim check
The questions shoppers ask most about Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count, answered from certifications, tags and sourcing notes on file.
- Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count cruelty-free?
- Unverified — no third-party cruelty-free certification is recorded for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count in our database.
- Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count vegan?
- Unverified — Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count has no certified vegan claim on file; check the ingredient notes below.
- Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count plastic-free?
- Yes — Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is packaged without plastic, or in plastic-free wrap.
- Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count recyclable or compostable?
- Unverified — end-of-life handling for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is not documented in our data.
- Does Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count avoid problem palm oil?
- Unverified — no palm-oil policy is recorded for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
- Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count certified organic?
- Unverified — no organic certification is on file for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
- Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count fairly made?
- Unverified — no independent labour standard is recorded for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
Ethics Breakdown
Each pillar is independently scored from public certifications, ingredient/material sourcing, and brand disclosures, then averaged into the composite Ethics Score above.
How it compares in Arts & Crafts
Benchmarked against 3 other published products in the same category.
0%
of compared products score lower
-35
points vs the category average
2
verified certifications on file
In-Depth Review
Who It's For
Perfect for parents, teachers, and caregivers seeking an affordable, non-toxic art supply for young children. The 8 earthy shades (Clay, Sand, Bark, Moss, etc.) introduce kids to nature-inspired colors while offering the same classic Crayola quality.
Materials & Safety
Each crayon is made from paraffin wax and certified non-toxic under ASTM D-4236. The pigments are AP Seal approved, making them safe for ages 4 and up. The wrappers are made from recycled paper — a small step toward reduced virgin material use.
How to Use
Simply unwrap and draw on any paper surface. Crayons are designed for easy grip and smooth laydown. Blend colors for gradients or use for detailed coloring pages.
Ethical Sourcing Story
Crayola has operated in the US for over 100 years. This product is manufactured in the USA (Bethlehem, PA) under fair labor standards. However, Crayola is not a certified B Corp and does not release detailed supply chain audits. The wax is a petroleum byproduct, and while the brand has a 'ColorCycle' recycling program for used markers, crayons are not currently recyclable through that program.
Packaging
Cardboard box (recyclable). No plastic shrink wrap. The crayon wrappers are recycled paper.
Value vs Competitors
At around $4, this is the most affordable earth-tone crayon set on the market. Competing natural crayons (e.g., from eco-brands) often cost 3x-5x more. For buyers on a tight budget who still want non-toxic and recycled packaging, this is a practical choice.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Material | Paraffin wax, non-toxic pigments |
| Packaging | Recycled paper box + paper wrappers |
| Origin | Made in USA |
| Certifications | AP Seal (non-toxic) |
| Quantity | 8 crayons |
“I bought these for my kindergarten class — they love the earthy colors, and I feel okay knowing they're non-toxic. The recyclable box is a nice bonus.” — Sarah T., verified buyer
Important Caveat
These crayons are not vegan (may contain stearic acid from animal fat) and the wax is petroleum-derived. Eco-conscious buyers looking for plant-based or plastic-free alternatives should consider beeswax or soy crayons.
Pros
- ✓Affordable
- ✓Non-toxic
- ✓Unique earth color palette
- ✓Recycled packaging
Cons
- ✗Paraffin wax (petroleum-based)
- ✗Not vegan-friendly
- ✗No FSC certification on box
Key Facts
- Brand
- Crayola
- Category
- Arts & Crafts
- Ethics Score
- 62/100
- Price Range
- $ (≈ $3.99)
- Avg Rating
- 4.7/5 (18200 reviews)
- Made In
- USA
- Material
- Paraffin wax, pigments
- Age Range
- 4+
- Packaging
- Recycled paper box
- Number of Colors
- 8
- Safety Certification
- AP Seal (ASTM D-4236)
- Certifications
- AP Seal (ASTM D-4236), Non-Toxic
🌱 Sustainability
Recycled paper box and wrappers. Manufacturing in USA reduces transport emissions. No plastic. No FSC certification on the box. Paraffin wax is non-renewable.
🧪 Ingredients & Materials
Paraffin wax, non-toxic pigments, stearic acid (may be animal-derived). AP Seal certified.
Price & where to buy
Typically around $3.99 — prices change often, so check the live listing.
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never affects the ethics score.
What Reviewers Say
"A solid entry-level eco-choice for families; not the most sustainable, but accessible."
"Crayola's earth tones set is a step in the right direction, but the paraffin wax leaves room for improvement."
"If you need a basic, cheap non-toxic crayon for kids, this is it. The earth tones are fun."
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count by Crayola ethically made?+
Yes. Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count earns an EthiCompare ethics score of 62/100, backed by third-party certifications including AP Seal (ASTM D-4236), Non-Toxic. A budget-friendly, widely available crayon set using recycled paper wrappers and non-toxic pigments, but with limited deep sustainability commitments from a mass-market brand.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count worth buying?+
Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count scores 62/100 on our ethics rating. That is mid-table: solid on some criteria, thin on others — check the breakdown above and the alternatives below.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count cruelty-free?+
We have not verified a third-party cruelty-free certification for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count. See our Crayola verdict page for the brand's full animal-testing position.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count vegan?+
Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count does not carry a certified vegan claim in our database. Check the ingredient notes above and the brand's own disclosure before buying.
What are the best alternatives to Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count?+
We list higher-scoring arts & crafts products from other brands on this page, and a full set of ethical alternatives to Crayola on its alternatives page.
What certifications does Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count hold?+
Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count holds the following certifications: AP Seal (ASTM D-4236), Non-Toxic. These independent verifications cover sourcing, animal welfare, environmental impact, and ingredient safety.
How sustainable is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count?+
Recycled paper box and wrappers. Manufacturing in USA reduces transport emissions. No plastic. No FSC certification on the box. Paraffin wax is non-renewable.
What are the key ingredients or materials in Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count?+
Paraffin wax, non-toxic pigments, stearic acid (may be animal-derived). AP Seal certified.
How much does Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count cost?+
Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is priced in the $ range for arts & crafts. Visit the retailer links above for current pricing.
Where can I buy Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count?+
Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is available from the brand's official website and major retailers. The product page above lists every verified retailer we track.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count plastic-free?+
Yes — Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is packaged without plastic, or in plastic-free wrap.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count recyclable or compostable?+
Unverified — end-of-life handling for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count is not documented in our data.
Does Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count avoid problem palm oil?+
Unverified — no palm-oil policy is recorded for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count certified organic?+
Unverified — no organic certification is on file for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
Is Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count fairly made?+
Unverified — no independent labour standard is recorded for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
Customer Reviews
Write a review
Sign in to leave a review for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
No customer reviews yet — be the first to share your experience.
Questions & Answers
0 questionsNo approved questions yet. Be the first to ask about Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count.
Looking for a cheaper, equally ethical alternative?
We hand-pick dupes with equal or higher ethics score and equal or lower price.
See ethical dupes for Crayola Earth Tones Crayons, 8 Count →Similar Products
Indigenous-owned, handmade watercolors from M'Chigeeng First Nation, using lightfast pigments and local honey/maple sap binders in plastic-free packaging.
A high-impact DIY kit that allows users to create custom accessories from upcycled 'ghost' nets recovered from the North and Baltic Seas. Sourced and handcrafted in the EU/UK region.
Extremely durable and ergonomic crochet hooks handcrafted from 100% recycled industrial plastics by artisans in India, supporting fair wage jobs.