Blueland Multi-Surface Starter Set vs EWG Verified All-Purpose Cleaner (Unscented)

Overview

Both the Blueland Multi-Surface Starter Set and AspenClean EWG Verified All-Purpose Cleaner (Unscented) earn an ethics score of 89/100, placing them among the top eco-friendly home cleaning products. However, they take very different approaches. Blueland focuses on reducing plastic waste through reusable spray bottles and concentrated tablets, while AspenClean offers a ready-to-use liquid in a recyclable bottle. Both are priced at the $$$ tier, meaning a higher upfront cost but long-term value for sustainable shoppers.

Ethics diff

While the overall ethics score is identical, the certifications tell a nuanced story. Blueland holds B Corp, Cradle to Cradle, EPA Safer Choice, Climate Neutral, and Leaping Bunny certifications, emphasizing supply chain transparency, material health, and carbon neutrality. AspenClean counters with EWG Verified, Ecologo, Leaping Bunny, Vegan, and Climate Neutral. The key difference: Blueland’s Cradle to Cradle certification guarantees rigorous ingredient and packaging safety, while AspenClean’s EWG Verified ensures no hidden toxins or fragrances. Both are climate neutral and cruelty-free, but Blueland’s B Corp status indicates a deeper commitment to social and environmental governance.

Everyday use

Blueland’s system requires you to fill their reusable bottle with water and drop in a tablet—a slight extra step but dramatically reduces plastic waste over time. The multi-surface cleaner works well on glass, counters, and floors, though some users note a light residue on mirrors. AspenClean is ready-to-spray, unscented, and free of dyes and irritants, making it ideal for sensitive skin or homes with pets. Its EWG certification assures no harsh fumes. Both clean effectively, but Blueland’s tablet system is better for bulk storage and travel, while AspenClean is more convenient for immediate use.

Value

Both cost $$$, but value depends on usage. Blueland’s starter set ($39) includes a reusable bottle and 3 tablets, each tablet making 20 oz—so about $0.65 per refill. AspenClean’s 32 oz bottle costs around $12, or $0.38 per oz, which is pricier per use. Over a year, Blueland can save money and landfill waste, especially for frequent cleaners. However, AspenClean’s lower barrier to entry (no initial bottle purchase) may appeal to those wanting to try without commitment.

Bottom line

This is a tie. Both products are excellent for eco-minded shoppers, with identical ethics scores and strong certifications. Blueland wins on waste reduction and long-term cost, while AspenClean wins on simplicity and skin-friendliness. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize zero-waste routines (Blueland) or ready-to-use, hypoallergenic cleaning (AspenClean).