Etta Star Necklace vs The Artisan Tassel Earrings

Overview

Both the Starfish Project Etta Star Necklace and the Able The Artisan Tassel Earrings are standout options in the ethical jewelry space, each earning an impressive 96 out of 100 on our ethics scale and priced in the mid-range ($$). The Starfish Project necklace features a delicate star pendant, crafted by artisans who have escaped human trafficking, while Able’s tassel earrings are handmade by women in Ethiopia, blending modern style with traditional craftsmanship. Both items boast sought-after certifications: the necklace is Fair Trade, PETA Approved, and B Corp certified; the earrings are Fair Trade, B Corp, and Climate Neutral certified.

Ethics diff

The ethics score is identical, but the certifications reveal different priorities. Starfish Project’s PETA Approved certification emphasizes a cruelty-free guarantee, meaning no animal-derived materials are used—ideal for vegan shoppers. Able’s Climate Neutral certification focuses on carbon footprint measurement and offsetting, appealing to environmentally conscious buyers. Both brands are deeply committed to social impact: Starfish Project supports survivors of exploitation, while Able invests in artisans’ economic empowerment and transparent supply chains. The ethical difference isn’t in quality but in which cause resonates more with you—animal welfare or climate action.

Everyday use

The Etta Star Necklace is a subtle, versatile piece that works well with both casual and professional attire. Its adjustable chain and lightweight design make it comfortable for all-day wear. The Artisan Tassel Earrings, with their colorful thread tassels and brass hooks, are statement makers—perfect for elevating a simple outfit but less suited for very active days. If you prefer understated elegance, choose the necklace; if you want to add a pop of personality, go with the earrings.

Value

Both offer strong value for their price range given the ethical backing. The necklace’s star pendant is timeless and likely to stay in style for years, while the earrings’ handmade tassels may show wear over time but are easily repairable or unique. The B Corp certification on both ensures accountability beyond profit. Neither product is the cheapest, but the cost reflects fair wages, safe working conditions, and environmental stewardship.

Bottom line

This is a tough tie—both items excel in ethics, price, and overall quality. Your choice comes down to personal style and which ethical impact matters most: animal cruelty (favor the necklace) or climate action (favor the earrings). For versatility and longevity, the Starfish Project necklace edges slightly ahead, while the Able earrings win on boldness and cultural storytelling. Either purchase supports a better world.