Garden Veggie Dog Treats with Real Cold-Pressed Peanut Butter vs Super-Food Dog Treats (Original Recipe)
Compare Jiminy's Garden Veggie Dog Treats (92/100) vs Chippin Super-Food Dog Treats (94/100). Ethics, price, certifications, and everyday use for ethical pet care.
Jiminy's
Garden Veggie Dog Treats with Real Cold-Pressed Peanut Butter
92/100 ethics
$$ · 3 certifications
View Garden Veggie Dog Treats with Real Cold-Pressed Peanut Butter →Chippin
WinnerSuper-Food Dog Treats (Original Recipe)
94/100 ethics
$$ · 3 certifications
View Super-Food Dog Treats (Original Recipe) →Ethics breakdown
| Dimension | Garden Veggie Dog Treats with Real Cold-Pressed Peanut Butter | Super-Food Dog Treats (Original Recipe) | Δ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sourcing | 98 | 96 | +2 |
| Labor | 85 | 92 | -7 |
| Environment | 95 | 98 | -3 |
| Animal welfare | 90 | 95 | -5 |
| Transparency | 92 | 90 | +2 |
| Overall ethics | 92 | 94 | -2 |
Why it wins
Chippin Super-Food Dog Treats achieve a higher ethics score (94/100) and hold the Certified Humane certification, plus they use upcycled and insect-based ingredients that further reduce environmental impact compared to Jiminy's peanut-based recipe.
Overview
Jiminy's Garden Veggie Dog Treats with Real Cold-Pressed Peanut Butter and Chippin Super-Food Dog Treats (Original Recipe) are both high-ethics, mid-priced dog treats. Jiminy's scores 92/100 with certifications including PETA Approved, Cruelty-Free, and B Corp, while Chippin scores higher at 94/100 and holds Certified Humane, Cruelty-Free, and PETA Approved certifications. Both are designed for health-conscious pet owners who prioritize animal welfare and sustainability.Ethics diff
The key ethical distinction lies in Chippin's use of upcycled ingredients (such as cricket protein) and its Certified Humane label, which includes rigorous animal welfare audits for ingredient sourcing. Jiminy's earns strong marks for being a B Corp, meaning it meets high social and environmental standards overall, but Chippin's slightly higher score reflects its emphasis on regenerative and waste-reducing practices. Both are cruelty-free and PETA Approved, ensuring no animal testing.Everyday use
Jiminy's treats are baked with real cold-pressed peanut butter, giving them a familiar, nutty flavor that many dogs love. They are ideal for training or daily rewards, with a soft yet chewy texture suitable for most sizes. Chippin's Super-Food treats are often denser and protein-rich, with a unique ingredient profile that includes insect-based protein—great for dogs with sensitivities to common meats or for owners seeking a more sustainable protein source. Both are free from artificial additives and made with whole ingredients.Value
Both products are priced at $$ (moderate range). Jiminy's may be slightly more widely available in eco-friendly pet stores, while Chippin's treats often come in larger bags per price point. The ethical premium is justified for both, but Chippin offers an edge in environmental impact due to its use of insects and upcycled foods, which require fewer resources than traditional peanut farming.Bottom line
While both are excellent, Chippin Super-Food Dog Treats win due to its higher ethics score (94 vs 92), inclusion of Certified Humane, and use of upcycled/insect-based ingredients that lower ecological footprint. Jiminy's is still a stellar choice if you prefer a classic peanut butter treat with B Corp certification.
An innovative, eco-friendly dog treat utilizing insect protein (grubs) to drastically reduce land and water usage compared to traditional livestock treats.

An eco-revolutionary dog treat powered by cricket protein, designed to reduce the carbon pawprint while providing a hypoallergenic, nutrient-dense snack that uses 99% less water than beef-based alternatives.
Not sold on either? Browse ethical alternatives
Each hub ranks the highest-scoring swaps in the same categories, on the same rubric.