All comparisons
Head-to-head

Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier (Orthodontic) vs Natural Rubber Soothers - Rounded

Compare HEVEA Orthodontic vs Natursutten Rounded natural rubber pacifiers. Both score 92/100 ethics at $$ price. Find out which soother wins for your baby.

HEVEA

Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier (Orthodontic)

92/100 ethics

$$ · 3 certifications

View Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier (Orthodontic) →

Natursutten

Natural Rubber Soothers - Rounded

92/100 ethics

$$ · 3 certifications

View Natural Rubber Soothers - Rounded →

Ethics breakdown

DimensionNatural Rubber Baby Pacifier (Orthodontic)Natural Rubber Soothers - RoundedΔ
Sourcing95950
Labor88880
Environment9896+2
Animal welfare1001000
Transparency9082+8
Overall ethics92920

Why it wins

Both HEVEA and Natursutten achieve identical ethics scores and price points, with distinct yet equally valid certifications. The choice hinges on personal preference for orthodontic vs. rounded shape or vegan vs. OEKO-TEX certifications, making neither a definitive winner.

Overview

Both HEVEA Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier (Orthodontic) and Natursutten Natural Rubber Soothers (Rounded) are top contenders in eco-friendly baby products. Each scores an impressive 92/100 on ethical standards and is priced at $$, making them accessible yet conscientious choices. HEVEA is certified by FSC, Vegan, and PETA Approved, emphasizing plant-based purity, while Natursutten holds FSC, Cruelty-Free, and OEKO-TEX certifications, focusing on skin safety and chemical-free production. Both are made from natural rubber, free from BPA, PVC, and phthalates, appealing to parents seeking non-toxic, sustainable soothers.

Ethics diff

The ethical distinction lies in certification focus. HEVEA’s PETA Approval and Vegan certification underscore a commitment to animal welfare and a fully plant-based product. Natursutten’s OEKO-TEX certification ensures rigorous testing for harmful substances, appealing to parents prioritizing chemical safety. Both brands are FSC Certified for responsible rubber sourcing, but HEVEA leans toward vegan advocacy, while Natursutten emphasizes hypoallergenic safety. Neither uses animal-derived materials, but the certifications reflect slightly different priorities: HEVEA for animal ethics, Natursutten for material purity.

Everyday use

HEVEA’s orthodontic shape is designed to support natural oral development, with a symmetrical nipple that adapts to baby’s mouth. It’s lightweight and has a soft texture but may flatten if chewed aggressively. Natursutten’s rounded shape mimics a mother’s nipple, often familiar to breastfed babies, and is slightly firmer, holding its shape well during sucking. Both soothers are one-piece construction, preventing choking hazards, and are easy to clean by boiling or steaming. The shield design on HEVEA is more curved for comfort, while Natursutten offers a slightly larger shield for safety. Parents report HEVEA is better for gassy babies due to its air vents, whereas Natursutten is praised for its longevity and resistance to tears.

Value

At the same price point ($$), both pacifiers offer similar lifespan and quality. However, HEVEA’s vegan certification may appeal to families with strict dietary ethics, while Natursutten’s OEKO-TEX badge reassures parents about chemical-free wear. Both are dishwasher-safe and durable for several months of use. In multi-packs, Natursutten sometimes offers a slightly lower per-unit cost, but HEVEA often includes a protective case. Overall, value is nearly equal, with a slight edge for Natursutten if budget-conscious parents seek maximum safety certifications.

Bottom line

Both pacifiers are excellent, sharing identical ethical scores and sustainability commitments. The winner depends on your priority: choose HEVEA for vegan-approved orthodontic design, or Natursutten for rigorous OEKO-TEX safety testing and a rounded shape preferred by breastfed babies. For most families, Natursutten’s chemical safety edge makes it a tie-breaker, but it’s a close call.

Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier (Orthodontic)
FSC CertifiedVeganPETA Approved

A plastic-free, 100% natural rubber pacifier handmade in Malaysia, designed to be biodegradable and safe for both infants and the ocean.

Natural Rubber Soothers - Rounded
92Excellent
FSC CertifiedCruelty-FreeOEKO-TEX

Handcrafted in Italy from 100% pure rubber from Hevea brasiliensis trees, this one-piece pacifier eliminates crevices where bacteria hide while ensuring zero plastic contact for infants.

Not sold on either? Browse ethical alternatives

Each hub ranks the highest-scoring swaps in the same categories, on the same rubric.