Ethical Dupes
Same kind of product · Comparable ethics score · Same or lower price tier · Office & Stationery. Picked from our independently scored catalogue.

Sorted by ethics score. Each card shows the difference from the original.

A popular, high-volume alternative to plastic pens, made from meadow grass and BPA-free plastic, featuring a safe, non-toxic ink formula.

High-quality, refillable pens made from recycled ocean-bound plastic. Designed by a woman-owned B Corp focused on zero-waste office supplies.

A refillable ballpoint pen made from meadow grass and recycled plastic, manufactured in a factory powered by biogas.

Caran d’Ache
Swiss-made, refillable ballpoint pen with a heritage-breed-inspired design (heirloom variety finish), crafted from recycled plastic and anodized aluminum. It has a slim, carry-on-friendly shape and timeless aesthetic. Pairs with the brand's subscription-available ink refills (Goliath giant cartridge) for a lifetime of use.
Certifications are as recorded on each listing; check the scheme's own directory for current scope.
| Product | Price tier | Ethics score | Certifications the original lacks |
|---|---|---|---|
| B Corp Certified Onyx and Green Retractable Bamboo PensOnyx and Green · original | $$ | 79/100 | — |
| Natural Grass Pen Set (Subscribe & Save)A Good Company | $$ | 96/100 | Climate Neutral, Vegan |
| Coastal Recycled Ocean Plastic Retractable PensWisdom Supply Co. | $ | 89/100 | 1% for the Planet, Global Recycled Standard |
| Natural Grass PenA Good Company | $ | 88/100 | Climate Neutral, Vegan |
| Caran d’Ache 849 Ecodesign Ballpoint Pen – Heirloom Edition (Refillable, Aluminum & Recycled Plastic)Caran d’Ache | $$ | 88/100 | Global Recycled Standard, Climate Neutral, PETA Approved |
A dupe must be the same type of item as the original — soap for soap, a carry-on for a carry-on — from a different brand in the same category.
Its EthiCompare ethics score can be at most 5 points below the original's. Most picks match or beat it; the difference is shown under each card.
It sits in the same or a lower price tier. Tiers are approximate bands, so check the retailer for today's price and size before comparing value.
Start with suitability, then compare the evidence. These checks are questions to investigate, not promises that every product in this ranking meets them.
The ethics score is a comparison of the information recorded in our catalogue, not a customer star rating, safety test or complete lifecycle assessment. Check the individual product's sources, certificate scope and current retailer details before deciding.
Scoring methodology →