All brands

Is Brilliant Earth ethical?

Recommended
92/100 EthiCompare ethics score · 3 scored products

Yes — Brilliant Earth scores 92/100 on EthiCompare, one of the stronger ratings in our database, with 1 of 3 ethics signals verified.

Brilliant Earth is a leading global retailer of ethically sourced jewelry, specializing in diamonds and gemstones with a focus on transparency and environmental responsibility. As a certified B Corp, the company maintains high standards for social and environmental performance while advocating for systemic reform in the jewelry industry.

Evidence table for Brilliant Earth
CheckStatusEvidence
Cruelty-freeunverifiedBrilliant Earth does not conduct animal testing; products are inorganic.
Vegan optionsunverifiedAll jewelry is free of animal-derived materials.
Third-party certifiedverifiedWe record 7 distinct certifications across this brand's products.
Certificationson fileB Corp, Climate Neutral, SCS Certified, Carbon Neutral, Responsible Jewellery Council

Scored with our public methodology. Profile last updated 2026-10-14.

Verified ethical brand

Brilliant Earth at a glance

Brilliant Earth offers 3 products on EthiCompare across Jewelry & Accessories, with an average ethics score of 92/10 and recurring certifications including B Corp, Climate Neutral, SCS Certified.

Is Brilliant Earth ethical and cruelty-free? Read the verdict
Ethics avg 92 3 products Price $$$$
Brilliant Earth

Our editorial read on Brilliant Earth

Written from this brand's own listings, recorded certifications and ownership records in our database — never from generated or marketing copy. How we research brands

What our catalogue shows

We currently track 3 Brilliant Earth products across Jewelry & Accessories. Each one is scored 0–100 on ethics using the certifications, ingredient and material disclosures, packaging claims and sourcing information attached to its listing.

Across the scored range, Brilliant Earth averages 92/100, with individual products between 92 and 92. The average describes only the products we have scored — it is not a verdict on every product the company sells.

The highest-scoring Brilliant Earth listing in our catalogue is 14k Gold 1ctw Bezel Set Diamond Earrings at 92/100, shown in the range table below with the rest of the line-up.

Certifications on file

The following credentials appear on Brilliant Earth's listings or brand profile in our database: B Corp, Climate Neutral, SCS Certified, Carbon Neutral, Responsible Jewellery Council, SCS Global Services, SCS Global Certified, Responsible Jewellery Council (RJC), FSC Certified. A certification is recorded when it appears on a product listing or the brand's published materials; we do not independently audit certificate scope, so confirm current status in the scheme's own directory before relying on it.

Recorded policies

Our records describe Brilliant Earth's animal-testing position as follows: "Does not conduct animal testing; products are inorganic."

Brilliant Earth is recorded as not selling through mainland China retail channels, which avoids the post-market testing risk attached to that market.

On vegan suitability, our records note: "All jewelry is free of animal-derived materials."

Brilliant Earth's stated sustainability commitments, as recorded in our database: "Aims for 100% recycled or Fairmined metals by 2025 and maintains Carbon Neutral status."

Policy statements above are the brand's own words as recorded in our database, shown so you can weigh them against the third-party credentials. Where a statement and a certification disagree, the certification is the stronger evidence.

Brilliant Earth ethics profile

Updated 10/14/2026

Overview

Founded in 2005, Brilliant Earth was established with the mission to cultivate a more ethical and transparent diamond industry. The brand positions itself as a luxury alternative to traditional jewelers by prioritizing 'Beyond Conflict Free' diamonds. This internal standard goes beyond the industry-standard Kimberley Process, which only addresses rebel-funded conflict, to include protection against human rights abuses, child labor, and environmental degradation. The company offers both natural diamonds with traceable origins and lab-grown diamonds, alongside jewelry made primarily from recycled precious metals.

Certifications

Brilliant Earth holds several high-level certifications that validate its operational ethics. Most notably, it is a certified B Corporation, meaning it has undergone rigorous assessment of its impact on workers, customers, community, and the environment. The brand is also a member of the Responsible Jewellery Council (RJC), the leading standards-setting organization for the entire jewelry and watch supply chain. Its lab-grown diamonds often carry SCS Global Services certification for sustainability, and the company utilizes Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certified materials for its packaging to ensure responsible forest management.

Animal testing & vegan range

As a fine jewelry retailer, Brilliant Earth does not conduct or commission animal testing, as its products (precious metals and gemstones) do not typically involve such processes in their development. While the brand does not market itself specifically as a 'vegan' company, its jewelry is inherently free of animal-derived components. The use of lab-grown diamonds and recycled metals further reduces the ecological footprint that can indirectly impact wildlife habitats compared to traditional open-pit mining operations.

Sustainability pledges

Brilliant Earth has committed to significant environmental goals, including achieving Carbon Neutrality. The company actively works to minimize its carbon footprint through the use of recycled gold and silver, which requires significantly less energy and water than newly mined metals. By 2025, the brand aims for 100% of its collections to be made from recycled or Fairmined-certified metals. Additionally, their packaging is designed to be eco-friendly, utilizing recycled materials and FSC-certified wood where possible.

Sourcing & labor

The brand's 'Beyond Conflict Free' sourcing policy is the cornerstone of its labor ethics. Brilliant Earth tracks its natural diamonds back to specific mines in countries like Canada, Botswana, and Namibia that follow strict labor and environmental laws. By avoiding diamonds from high-risk areas where labor exploitation is common, the company ensures a cleaner supply chain. For their lab-grown diamonds, they prioritize suppliers that use renewable energy. Furthermore, the brand supports artisanal mining communities through its various charitable initiatives and gemstones sourced via the 'Moyo Gem' project, which empowers female miners in Tanzania and Kenya.

Controversies context

While Brilliant Earth has faced minor criticisms typical of large-scale retailers—primarily revolving around the complexities of proving 100% traceability in a global commodity market—there are no major environmental or human rights controversies on record. The company has proactively addressed industry-wide transparency issues by integrating blockchain technology to provide customers with verifiable digital footprints for their diamonds. Unlike many traditional competitors, Brilliant Earth has maintained a clean record regarding labor disputes and ecological disasters.

Bottom line

Brilliant Earth remains a top-tier choice for consumers seeking luxury jewelry without the ethical baggage of the traditional diamond trade. With a 92/100 ethics rating and a robust suite of certifications including B Corp and SCS Global, the brand demonstrates a genuine commitment to social and environmental progress. Its focus on recycled metals and traceable gemstones makes it a leader in the sustainable jewelry sector.

Certifications

B CorpCarbon NeutralSCS CertifiedResponsible Jewellery Council (RJC)FSC Certified

Sustainability pledges

Aims for 100% recycled or Fairmined metals by 2025 and maintains Carbon Neutral status.

Animal testing policy

Brilliant Earth does not conduct animal testing; products are inorganic.

Vegan range

All jewelry is free of animal-derived materials.

Sold in mainland China

No — avoids mainland China retail channels.

Standards & certifications

Verified credentials appearing across Brilliant Earth's product range.

B Corp ×3Climate Neutral ×2SCS Certified ×1Carbon Neutral ×1Responsible Jewellery Council ×1SCS Global Services ×1SCS Global Certified ×1

Ethics breakdown

Average scores across our scoring pillars.

  • Animal Welfare100/10
  • Sourcing97.7/10
  • Transparency95.3/10
  • Environment93/10
  • Labor91.7/10

Categories covered

Where Brilliant Earth shows up across our directory.

  • Jewelry & Accessories3

What reviewers highlight

Strengths mentioned most often across Brilliant Earth's products.

  • ✓Unmatched transparency in the supply chain
  • ✓High-quality recycled materials
  • ✓Stunning fire and brilliance
  • ✓Highly customizable stone and metal options
  • ✓Exceptional transparency and sourcing documentation
  • ✓Elegant, timeless design that fits most wedding bands

Range at a glance

How consistent Brilliant Earth is across everything we have scored.

3

products scored

92–92

ethics score range

100%

carry a certification

$$$$

price tiers

ProductCategoryPriceEthics
14k Gold 1ctw Bezel Set Diamond EarringsJewelry & Accessories$$$$92
Classic 6-Prong Solitaire Engagement RingJewelry & Accessories$$$$92
14k Gold 1ctw Round Lab-Grown Diamond Stud EarringsJewelry & Accessories$$$$92

Brand ethics profile

Brilliant Earth is a leading global retailer of ethically sourced jewelry, specializing in diamonds and gemstones with a focus on transparency and environmental responsibility. As a certified B Corp, the company maintains high standards for social and environmental performance while advocating for systemic reform in the jewelry industry.

Animal-testing policy
Brilliant Earth does not conduct animal testing; products are inorganic.
Sold in mainland China
No — avoids mainland China channels.
Vegan range
All jewelry is free of animal-derived materials.
Sustainability pledges
Aims for 100% recycled or Fairmined metals by 2025 and maintains Carbon Neutral status.
B CorpCarbon NeutralSCS CertifiedResponsible Jewellery Council (RJC)FSC Certified

Controversy timeline

(4 recorded)
  1. Medium

    Greenwashing Complaint Filed with U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC)

    In 2022, a complaint was filed with the FTC by a consumer advocacy group alleging Brilliant Earth's 'sustainably sourced' and 'ethical' marketing claims amounted to greenwashing. The complaint argued that the company had not provided verifiable evidence for these claims and that its reliance on mined diamonds and metals contradicted the promises. The FTC has not publicly announced an enforcement action, but the complaint remains a matter of public record.

    Source
  2. Medium

    Class Action Lawsuit Over Misleading 'Ethical' and 'Eco-Friendly' Claims

    In 2021, a class action lawsuit was filed against Brilliant Earth alleging the company misrepresented its diamonds as 'ethically sourced' and 'eco-friendly' when in fact many diamonds came from suppliers with questionable labor and environmental practices. The suit claimed the company's marketing deceived consumers into paying premium prices. The case was eventually dismissed in 2022, but the allegations highlighted ongoing scrutiny over supply chain transparency.

    Source
  3. High

    Worker Rights Allegations at Brilliant Earth's Jewelry Suppliers

    In 2019, a report by the human rights organization International Rights Advocates documented forced labor and hazardous working conditions at gold mines in Peru that supplied Brilliant Earth and other retailers. The report alleged that artisanal miners, including children, faced mercury poisoning and lack of safety equipment. Brilliant Earth denied direct ties but stated it would review its supply chain. The allegations were part of a broader lawsuit against several companies.

    Source
  4. Medium

    Recall of Diamond Stud Earrings Due to Choking Hazard

    In 2018, Brilliant Earth voluntarily recalled approximately 2,300 pairs of diamond stud earrings after discovering that the earring backs could detach and pose a choking hazard. The recall was conducted in cooperation with the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). Consumers were offered a full refund or replacement. No injuries were reported.

    Source

Sustainability commitments

"The gold is sourced from repurposed electronics and old jewelry. Diamonds are grown in facilities powered by renewable energy."

"Packaging is made from FSC-certified wood and recycled materials; company is a certified Climate Neutral entity."

"The brand is a certified B Corp and maintains Climate Neutral Status. They utilize 100% recycled precious metals for the majority of their products to minimize ecological impact."

All Brilliant Earth products

3 of 3 products

14k Gold 1ctw Bezel Set Diamond Earrings
92Excellent
SCS CertifiedB CorpCarbon NeutralResponsible Jewellery Council

Luxury lab-grown diamond studs featuring ethically sourced recycled 14k gold and Beyond Conflict Free™ standards.

Classic 6-Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring
92Excellent
B CorpClimate NeutralSCS Global Services

A quintessential ethical engagement ring featuring Beyond Conflict Free™ diamonds and recycled precious metals, backed by industry-leading transparency standards.

14k Gold 1ctw Round Lab-Grown Diamond Stud Earrings
B CorpClimate NeutralSCS Global Certified

Superior ethical alternative to mined diamonds, featuring carbon-neutral lab diamonds set in recycled 14k gold. A timeless staple for the conscious consumer seeking luxury without the environmental or social toll of traditional mining.

Common questions about Brilliant Earth

Is Brilliant Earth cruelty-free?+

We have no cruelty-free certification on file for Brilliant Earth's scored products. Absence of a certification is not proof of animal testing, but it does mean nothing independent has been verified.

How does Brilliant Earth score overall?+

Brilliant Earth averages 92/100 across the 3 products we have scored, using public certifications, sourcing disclosures and controversy records.

Who owns Brilliant Earth?+

Parent-company ownership changes what your money supports. See our brand ownership map for the current group structure and any conflicting parent-company records.

What are the best alternatives to Brilliant Earth?+

Our alternatives page ranks comparable products by ethics score with a side-by-side difference table, so you can see exactly which pillar improves.