Is Brilliant Earth ethical and cruelty-free?
Yes — Brilliant Earth scores 92/100 on EthiCompare, one of the stronger ratings in our database, with 1 of 3 ethics signals verified.
Brilliant Earth is a leading global retailer of ethically sourced jewelry, specializing in diamonds and gemstones with a focus on transparency and environmental responsibility. As a certified B Corp, the company maintains high standards for social and environmental performance while advocating for systemic reform in the jewelry industry.
The evidence, signal by signal
Cruelty-freeunverified
Brilliant Earth does not conduct animal testing; products are inorganic.
Vegan optionsunverified
All jewelry is free of animal-derived materials.
Third-party certifiedverified
We record 7 distinct certifications across this brand's products.
Public pledges: Aims for 100% recycled or Fairmined metals by 2025 and maintains Carbon Neutral status.
Scored with our public methodology. Profile last updated 2026-10-14.
Before you buy
Start with suitability, then compare the evidence. These checks are questions to investigate, not promises that every product in this ranking meets them.
- Ask what the sourcing claim covers: the metal, stones or entire piece, and whether chain-of-custody evidence is available.
- Check plating, base metals and allergy information before buying, particularly for everyday wear.
- Compare repair, resizing and secondhand options; a recycled-metal claim alone does not cover mining or labour risks in every component.
What the ranking does—and does not—tell you
The ethics score is a comparison of the information recorded in our catalogue, not a customer star rating, safety test or complete lifecycle assessment. Check the individual product's sources, certificate scope and current retailer details before deciding.
Scoring methodology →Controversy timeline
(4 recorded)- Medium
Greenwashing Complaint Filed with U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
In 2022, a complaint was filed with the FTC by a consumer advocacy group alleging Brilliant Earth's 'sustainably sourced' and 'ethical' marketing claims amounted to greenwashing. The complaint argued that the company had not provided verifiable evidence for these claims and that its reliance on mined diamonds and metals contradicted the promises. The FTC has not publicly announced an enforcement action, but the complaint remains a matter of public record.
Source - Medium
Class Action Lawsuit Over Misleading 'Ethical' and 'Eco-Friendly' Claims
In 2021, a class action lawsuit was filed against Brilliant Earth alleging the company misrepresented its diamonds as 'ethically sourced' and 'eco-friendly' when in fact many diamonds came from suppliers with questionable labor and environmental practices. The suit claimed the company's marketing deceived consumers into paying premium prices. The case was eventually dismissed in 2022, but the allegations highlighted ongoing scrutiny over supply chain transparency.
Source - High
Worker Rights Allegations at Brilliant Earth's Jewelry Suppliers
In 2019, a report by the human rights organization International Rights Advocates documented forced labor and hazardous working conditions at gold mines in Peru that supplied Brilliant Earth and other retailers. The report alleged that artisanal miners, including children, faced mercury poisoning and lack of safety equipment. Brilliant Earth denied direct ties but stated it would review its supply chain. The allegations were part of a broader lawsuit against several companies.
Source - Medium
Recall of Diamond Stud Earrings Due to Choking Hazard
In 2018, Brilliant Earth voluntarily recalled approximately 2,300 pairs of diamond stud earrings after discovering that the earring backs could detach and pose a choking hazard. The recall was conducted in cooperation with the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). Consumers were offered a full refund or replacement. No injuries were reported.
Source
Brilliant Earth products we score

Luxury lab-grown diamond studs featuring ethically sourced recycled 14k gold and Beyond Conflict Free™ standards.

A quintessential ethical engagement ring featuring Beyond Conflict Free™ diamonds and recycled precious metals, backed by industry-leading transparency standards.

Superior ethical alternative to mined diamonds, featuring carbon-neutral lab diamonds set in recycled 14k gold. A timeless staple for the conscious consumer seeking luxury without the environmental or social toll of traditional mining.
Better-scoring alternatives to Brilliant Earth
Products from other brands in the same categories with higher stored ethics scores. Check each recorded certification before you switch.

A premium, biodegradable beanie made from seed-to-garment organic cotton under strict fair trade conditions.

A rugged, carbon-neutral backpack made from Fairtrade-certified organic cotton canvas, designed to eliminate plastic waste from the accessories industry.

A fully compostable and vegan watch strap made from apple waste and bio-polymers, offering a sustainable alternative to animal leather and silicone.

Handcrafted in Kenya using a mobile-tech platform to connect independent artisans with global markets, these hoops are a masterpiece of ethical fashion.

A rugged, carbon-neutral everyday backpack made from GOTS certified organic cotton canvas in a Fair Trade Factory, providing a sustainable alternative to polyester bags.

A stunning hand-stitched scarf made from organic cotton and vintage silk by marginalized women in India.
More on Brilliant Earth
Is Brilliant Earth ethical? FAQs
Is Brilliant Earth cruelty-free?+
Brilliant Earth does not conduct animal testing; products are inorganic.
Does Brilliant Earth have vegan products?+
All jewelry is free of animal-derived materials.
What is Brilliant Earth's ethics score?+
Brilliant Earth averages 92/100 across 3 products we score on certifications, sourcing, labour, packaging and transparency.
What are the best alternatives to Brilliant Earth?+
Higher-scoring alternatives include Organic Cotton Beanie by Kowtow, The Terra Backpack by Terra Thread, Renewable Apple Leather Watch Band by Pela.