Bamboo Toilet Paper (3-Ply) vs The Menstrual Cup

Overview

Who Gives A Crap Bamboo Toilet Paper (3-Ply) and Saalt The Menstrual Cup are two standout products in the Health & Wellness category, each earning an impressive 96/100 ethics score. The former is a premium, eco-friendly toilet paper made from bamboo, while the latter is a reusable menstrual cup designed for period care. Both are B Corp certified, but they serve very different daily needs. Who Gives A Crap is certified FSC and Vegan, focusing on sustainable bathroom habits. Saalt carries Cruelty-Free, Leaping Bunny, and 1% for the Planet certifications, emphasizing animal welfare and environmental philanthropy.

Ethics diff

While both products share the same high ethics rating, their certifications highlight distinct ethical priorities. Who Gives A Crap excels in sustainable sourcing (FSC-certified bamboo) and is fully vegan, making it ideal for those focused on deforestation-free materials and plant-based living. Saalt, on the other hand, prioritizes cruelty-free testing (Leaping Bunny) and donates 1% of sales to environmental causes through 1% for the Planet, appealing to consumers who value animal rights and direct impact giving. Both support social missions: Who Gives A Crap donates 50% of profits to water and sanitation charities, while Saalt focuses on period poverty solutions.

Everyday use

Who Gives A Crap Bamboo Toilet Paper offers a soft, strong 3-ply experience suitable for daily bathroom use. It is absorbent, septic-safe, and comes in plastic-free packaging with fun, colorful patterns. However, some users find bamboo TP slightly less soft than conventional premium brands. Saalt The Menstrual Cup requires a learning curve for insertion and removal but provides up to 12 hours of leak-free protection, reducing waste from disposable pads or tampons. It is a one-time purchase that lasts years, making it a low-maintenance option after the initial adjustment. Both products aim to replace disposable items, but the cup offers a more radical reduction in waste by being reusable.

Value

At first glance, both are pricey ($$$). Who Gives A Crap charges a premium for their 3-ply bamboo rolls, typically costing about $0.04–$0.06 per square foot, which is comparable to high-end recycled brands. Saalt’s menstrual cup costs around $30–$40, but since it lasts 2–5 years, it saves money over time compared to buying disposable period products monthly. From a cost-per-use perspective, Saalt offers far greater long-term value, while Who Gives A Crap provides ongoing sustainable luxury for a recurring purchase. The choice depends on your budget horizon and whether you prefer a one-time investment or a subscription model.

Bottom line

Both products are ethically excellent, but they serve different needs. If you seek a sustainable upgrade for a daily necessity (toilet paper), choose Who Gives A Crap. If you want to minimize waste and save money long-term on period care, choose Saalt. As a direct comparison, Saalt edges ahead due to its reusable nature and lower lifetime environmental impact, making it a more transformative ethical choice.