All comparisons
Head-to-head

Open Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food vs Wild Earth Clean Protein Dog Food

Compare Open Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains (94/100) vs Wild Earth Clean Protein (96/100) for ethical pet care. See which wins on certifications, nutrition, and value.

Open Farm

Open Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food

94/100 ethics

$$$ · 4 certifications

View Open Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food →

Wild Earth

Winner

Wild Earth Clean Protein Dog Food

96/100 ethics

$$$ · 4 certifications

View Wild Earth Clean Protein Dog Food →

Ethics breakdown

DimensionOpen Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains Dry Dog FoodWild Earth Clean Protein Dog FoodΔ
Sourcing9897+1
Labor90900
Environment9599-4
Animal welfare96100-4
Transparency10095+5
Overall ethics9496-2

Why it wins

Wild Earth wins due to its higher ethics score (96/100), completely vegan and cruelty-free formulation, and PETA approval, which align with the most stringent animal welfare standards, while Open Farm relies on animal protein despite humane certifications.

Overview

Open Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food and Wild Earth Clean Protein Dog Food are both premium, ethically-driven options for conscientious pet owners. Open Farm (ethics 94/100, $$$) focuses on humanely raised, ocean-wise salmon with whole grains, while Wild Earth (ethics 96/100, $$$) offers a vegan, protein-packed formula made from fungi and oats. Both carry a 1% for the Planet certification, but differ in their sourcing philosophies and nutritional profiles.

Ethics diff

Wild Earth earns a slightly higher ethics score (96 vs 94) due to its comprehensive plant-based approach: it is Vegan, Cruelty-Free, and PETA Approved, avoiding any animal suffering or byproducts. Open Farm, while strong, relies on animal protein and holds Certified Humane and Ocean Wise certifications, which ensure welfare and sustainable fishing but still involve animal life. Both support environmental causes through 1% for the Planet. If maximizing animal liberation is your priority, Wild Earth leads; if you prefer sustainable animal agriculture, Open Farm is solid.

Everyday use

Open Farm’s salmon recipe is ideal for dogs that thrive on protein-rich, grain-inclusive diets. It features salmon as the first ingredient, plus ancient grains like oats and millet for fiber and energy—great for active dogs. Wild Earth’s Clean Protein formula uses yeast as a complete protein source (with added pea protein and oats), making it hypoallergenic and gentle on sensitive stomachs. Both are highly digestible, but Wild Earth may suit dogs with meat allergies or owners seeking a fully vegan lifestyle. Neither contains artificial preservatives or fillers.

Value

Both are priced at three dollar signs ($$$), reflecting their premium ethical sourcing. Open Farm typically costs around $55–$65 for a 22-lb bag, while Wild Earth is about $50–$60 for a 24-lb bag, making them comparable per pound. However, Wild Earth may offer slightly better value for those seeking a complete protein source without farmed animal inputs. Open Farm’s certification costs (Certified Humane, Ocean Wise) add to its price but guarantee traceability. Consider your budget and ethical priorities—both are investments in responsible pet care.

Bottom line

If you prioritize a fully vegan, cruelty-free, and PETA-approved diet that avoids animal products entirely, choose Wild Earth (winner). If you prefer a sustainable, humanely sourced animal protein with grain inclusion and oceanic consciousness, Open Farm is excellent but trails slightly in overall ethics. For the most progressive ethical stance with strong nutrition, Wild Earth takes the lead.
Open Farm Salmon & Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food
Certified HumaneOcean WiseB Corp1% for the Planet

A premium, fully traceable dry dog food featuring wild-caught Alaskan salmon and nutrient-dense ancient grains, prioritized for animal welfare and environmental transparency.

Wild Earth Clean Protein Dog Food
96Excellent
VeganCruelty-FreePETA Approved1% for the Planet

A high-protein, plant-based dog food that drastically reduces the environmental impact of pet ownership without sacrificing nutrition.

Not sold on either? Browse ethical alternatives

Each hub ranks the highest-scoring swaps in the same categories, on the same rubric.