Methodology: understanding the ethics score
Evidence, uncertainty and the limits of a single number.
An ethical ranking is useful only when you can question what it represents. This guide explains how the current catalogue assessment works and what needs independent verification before a purchase.
Key takeaways
- Every EthiCompare rating is a 0–100 AI-assisted catalogue assessment with five recorded dimensions, not a pass/fail badge or an audit.
- Certifications are auditable evidence; adjectives like "natural", "green" or "conscious" are not.
- Missing disclosure limits what can be assessed — we never assume the best case for an unanswered question.
- Ownership matters: a certified brand inside a group that still tests where the law demands it is a different decision.
- Scores are reviewed when the catalogue is refreshed, so check the named certificate or policy before relying on a number.
In this guide
- What the published ethics score measures
- How to judge the strength of the supporting evidence
- Missing information and small score differences
- Ethics scores, customer ratings and prices stay separate
- Updates, corrections and the limits of freshness
- How to use this page in four steps
- What to look for before you buy
- Label decoder: claims vs. certifications
- Terms you will see on this page
- Frequently asked questions

What the published ethics score measures
The 0–100 ethics score is a catalogue assessment intended to help compare products, not a laboratory result or an official certification. Product records also contain a five-part breakdown for sourcing, labour, environment, animal welfare and transparency. These fields make different concerns visible, but a single total inevitably compresses trade-offs. A product can be stronger on one issue and weaker on another, so a high total does not establish that it satisfies every personal requirement.
There is an important distinction between the editorial criteria described on this site and the way a listing's score enters the catalogue. The current automated importer asks AI to propose both the total and the five breakdown values, and saves them as structured fields. It does not derive every total through a reproducible, fixed-weight calculation from independently verified evidence. The published score therefore needs to be read critically alongside sources and product notes; it should not be described as an independently audited measurement.
How to judge the strength of the supporting evidence
A current certificate covering the relevant product is stronger support for a certification claim than a retailer badge. A dated supplier list is useful evidence of disclosure, but it does not by itself establish living wages or safe conditions at every factory. A brand's sustainability report can explain its stated actions while still being self-reported. Identify what a document actually supports, who produced it, the time period it covers and which entity it concerns before accepting a broader conclusion.
The product importer's web check is a brand-existence safeguard, not a full product audit. It reduces the risk of publishing an invented brand; it does not independently confirm every certification, ingredient, price, review or score proposed by AI. When a claim is important to your purchase, follow the source back to the manufacturer, certifier or relevant authority. A fluent summary, a convincing photograph and a precise-looking number are not substitutes for that verification.
Missing information and small score differences
An undisclosed fact and a negative finding are different. Missing supplier information means you cannot assess that part of the chain confidently; it is not proof that abuse occurred. Equally, the absence of a controversy entry is not proof of an unblemished history. Catalogue coverage depends on the information available, the entities searched and the dates of the sources. Small businesses may provide less formal documentation even when they have useful practices, while large businesses can publish extensive reports that leave important questions unanswered.
There is no validated uncertainty margin that makes a one- or two-point gap a meaningful difference in real-world impact. Compare products with the same intended use and inspect the dimensions that matter to you. For example, if both detergents meet your practical needs but only one has a verifiable animal-testing policy, that policy can be a more useful tie-breaker than an 82 versus an 84. This is a hypothetical decision example, not a measured comparison of catalogue products.
Ethics scores, customer ratings and prices stay separate
An ethics score summarises the catalogue's ethical assessment. A star rating describes reported customer experience, where genuine review evidence is available. A price describes an offer at a particular point in time. These signals answer different questions. A product can be popular with customers while lacking transparent sourcing, or have useful ethical evidence while being unsuitable for your skin, dimensions or budget. Do not interpret customer satisfaction as independent proof of environmental or labour performance.
Before relying on a review summary, check the source, product variant, review count and date where supplied. AI-assisted catalogue text is not a customer review, and a retailer rating is not a rating of the brand's ethics. Likewise, a dollar-sign tier is a rough price grouping, not a numerical offer. Always check a retailer's current product page and checkout total. Keeping these distinctions clear is more informative than combining them into an apparently authoritative recommendation.
Updates, corrections and the limits of freshness
Catalogue records and editorial pages are maintained through separate update processes. A recent page refresh does not establish that every source, certificate or supplier fact was checked again that day. Read dates on the underlying documents and distinguish a new summary from new evidence. Changes to ownership, formulas, packaging or certification scope can make an older conclusion less useful even when the product name remains the same.
If you spot a problem, report the exact product or page through our press and contact page. Include the disputed claim, a link to the original evidence, its date and the relevant product or company scope. This makes a correction easier to assess than a general statement that a score is wrong. Do not use this catalogue as a safety approval, medical recommendation, legal finding or a complete lifecycle assessment; it is a starting point for informed comparison, with important limitations made explicit.
How to use this page in four steps
The guide below explains the thinking; this is the fastest route from question to decision.
- 1
Start with the score
The 0–100 number tells you where a product or brand sits against everything else we track in the same category.
- 2
Open the evidence
Each pillar links to the certification, policy page or report behind it, so you can verify the claim yourself.
- 3
Check the ownership
Parent-company policies can override a brand's own promises in markets where testing or sourcing rules differ.
- 4
Compare alternatives
Every page ends with better-scoring options in the same category and price band, so switching takes one click.
What to look for before you buy
A ranking gets you to a shortlist; these checks tell you whether a specific product is right for your household. Work through them in order — the first two rule out most greenwashing on their own.
- Check the certification, not the adjective: a logo from Leaping Bunny, Vegan Society, GOTS, Fair Trade or B Corp is auditable; the words "natural" and "clean" are not.
- Look up the parent company — a certified brand owned by a group that still tests where the law requires it is a different decision than an independent one.
- Read the full ingredient or material list, not the front-of-pack claim; a single animal-derived or high-impact input can undo the rest.
- Prefer refills, concentrates and take-back schemes: packaging is usually the fastest win in this category.
- Compare cost per use rather than shelf price, including dose, refill costs and how long you will actually use the item.
- Buy the thing you will actually finish or wear a hundred times; the lowest-impact purchase is still the one you do not replace.
Label decoder: claims vs. certifications
Most on-pack wording is unregulated. Use this table to translate a claim into what it actually guarantees, and what to ask the brand when it does not.
| Claim on pack | What it actually guarantees | What to check instead |
|---|---|---|
| Cruelty-free | Nothing on its own — the term is not legally defined in the EU, UK or US. | A Leaping Bunny or Cruelty Free International logo, plus confirmation the brand does not sell where testing is required. |
| Vegan | Usually no animal-derived ingredients, but self-declared and rarely covers processing aids. | Vegan Society or V-Label certification, and whether shared equipment is used. |
| Natural / clean | Nothing. Both terms are marketing language with no standard behind them. | The full INCI or material list, and an organic certification such as GOTS, COSMOS or EU organic. |
| Eco-friendly / green | Nothing verifiable; increasingly restricted by EU greenwashing rules. | A specific, measured claim — recycled content percentage, certified supply chain, or a published footprint. |
| Recyclable | Technically recyclable somewhere, not necessarily in your municipal system. | Whether the pack is mono-material, and whether the brand runs a take-back or refill scheme. |
| Carbon neutral | Often offsets rather than reductions, and offsets vary wildly in quality. | Absolute emissions cuts against a base year and a validated science-based target. |
Terms you will see on this page
Plain-English definitions of the labels, standards and jargon used across EthiCompare.
- Leaping Bunny
- The strictest international cruelty-free standard: a fixed cut-off date for animal testing, supplier declarations and third-party audits.
- GOTS
- Global Organic Textile Standard — certified organic fibre content plus environmental and social criteria along the whole supply chain.
- B Corp
- A company-level certification scoring governance, workers, community, environment and customers; re-verified every three years.
- Fair Trade
- Certification guaranteeing minimum prices and a community premium to producers, with audited labour standards.
- Greenwashing
- Environmental marketing that is vague, unverifiable or unrepresentative of the product's real footprint.
- Cost per use
- Price divided by realistic lifetime uses — the number that shows whether a durable or concentrated product is actually cheaper.
Frequently asked questions
Is every score a fixed-weight calculation?+
No. The current importer asks AI to propose a total and five breakdown values and stores them; it does not calculate every total with a reproducible fixed-weight formula.
Does the importer verify all product claims?+
No. Its web check helps prevent invented brands, but does not independently verify every certification, ingredient, review, price or score.
How can I request a correction?+
Use the press and contact page with the exact claim, affected product, original source and date.
Does EthiCompare accept payment from brands?+
No. Rankings are never sold and no brand can pay to appear, move up or remove a controversy. Where affiliate links exist they never influence a score, and the methodology is public.
How often are scores updated?+
Certifications, policies and controversies are re-checked continuously and each page shows when its underlying profile was last updated. Material changes — a lost certification, a new testing policy — are reflected as soon as they are verified.
What happens when a brand does not answer?+
Unanswered questions score as unverified, not as positive. That deliberately penalises silence: transparency is one of the five pillars and it is worth 15% of the total.
Is the guide available in other languages?+
Yes — every guide is published in English, Spanish, German and French with fully translated content, and the language switcher at the top keeps you on the same page.
Keep reading
Browse: every product, scored on the things that matter
Filter by your values, not by advertising spend.
Brand transparency: the company behind the label
Ownership, disclosure and a dated record of what each brand has been caught doing.
Label & Certification Lookup: what the logo actually proves
Every mark, what it audits — and what it quietly leaves out.
Reviewed and maintained by the EthiCompare editorial team.