Wild Earth Performance Formula Plant-Based Dog Food vs Open Farm Freeze Dried Raw Harvest Chicken Dog Food

Overview

Both Wild Earth Performance Formula Plant-Based Dog Food and Open Farm Freeze Dried Raw Harvest Chicken Dog Food earn an identical ethics score of 92/100 and are premium-priced ($$$). However, they represent two fundamentally different philosophies in pet nutrition. Wild Earth is a completely plant-based, vegan formula aimed at reducing animal agriculture’s environmental impact, while Open Farm offers a freeze-dried raw diet centered on high-quality animal protein from ethically sourced chicken.

Ethics diff

Although their overall ethics ratings match, the certifications tell distinct stories. Wild Earth carries Vegan, Cruelty-Free, PETA Approved, and 1% for the Planet labels, emphasizing animal welfare and environmental giving. Open Farm holds B Corp, Leaping Bunny (cruelty-free), and Non-GMO certifications, focusing on corporate responsibility and ingredient transparency. Wild Earth’s ethics are rooted in avoiding animal products altogether, whereas Open Farm’s ethics center on humane animal farming and supply chain integrity.

Everyday use

Wild Earth’s plant-based kibble is designed as a complete and balanced diet, suitable for dogs with chicken or meat allergies, and is shelf-stable with easy portioning. Open Farm’s freeze-dried raw requires rehydration or can be fed as a topper, offering a minimally processed option but demanding more preparation. Wild Earth is simpler for busy owners; Open Farm appeals to those seeking a raw or fresh-food experience without freezer storage.

Value

Both products are expensive, but the value proposition differs. Wild Earth’s price reflects its innovative vegan formulation and sustainability mission, though some pet parents question the long-term benefits of plant-based diets for carnivorous dogs. Open Farm’s cost is justified by high-quality animal protein, freeze-drying process, and third-party certifications. If your priority is a direct, traceable meat source, Open Farm offers clearer value; if reducing environmental pawprint matters most, Wild Earth aligns better.

Bottom line

This is a true tie. For ethically minded shoppers, the winner depends on dietary philosophy: choose Wild Earth for plant-based, cruelty-free nutrition that challenges traditional pet food, or Open Farm for responsibly sourced animal protein with raw benefits. Both excel in ethics, but serve different pet care visions.